The best signals for cold email depend on the industry you sell into. We built this Claude skill to answer that question from data rather than opinion. It cross-references 1,000,000+ cold emails sent through Smartlead with 300+ Clay enrichment tables, and maps each signal to the positive replies it produced.
Once the skill sits in a Claude Project, every conversation in that project knows which signals work for which vertical. It can then pick the enrichments for a Clay table and shape the email around them.
Where the data comes from
- Smartlead: 1,000,000+ cold emails across 200+ campaigns and 8 verticals, from April 2024 to March 2026.
- Clay: 300+ enrichment tables covering company news, funding, hiring, tech stack changes, partnerships and leadership changes.
- Positive replies analysed: 10,102, counting information requests, interested replies and meeting requests.
- Method: every first-touch email was traced back to the Clay signal behind its opener, then matched to positive reply rates by vertical.
From that work came 15 distinct signal types. The skill ranks them by how often they appeared and shows where each one helped or hurt.
What the data showed against the common advice
| Common advice | What the data showed |
|---|---|
| Use hiring signals | Hiring signals sat in the lowest-performing vertical, manufacturing, at a 0.9% positive rate |
| Use funding signals | Funding appeared in 6.3% of emails and worked clearly only in creative services, at a 6.5% positive rate |
| Expansion signals are gold | Expansion appeared in about 40% of emails with middling results in most verticals |
| More signals means better personalisation | The top vertical, EdTech at 17.9%, used no traditional intent signals at all |
| Company-level signals are key | In recruiting, at 6.7%, only person-level signals worked |
The pattern behind every row is relevance. A signal helps when it connects to the reason this buyer would act now. It adds little when it only proves you looked at their LinkedIn page.
The best signals for cold email, vertical by vertical
| Vertical | Positive reply rate | Winning combination |
|---|---|---|
| EdTech / Education | 17.9% | Geographic targeting, free pilot, case study |
| B2B services / agency | 9.0% | Partnership or expansion news, case study |
| Real estate tech | 6.8% | Thought leadership, business model analysis, industry pain point |
| Assessments / HR tech | 6.7% | Hiring signal, free pilot |
| Recruiting / talent | 6.7% | Tenure, role pain points, hiring context |
| Video / creative services | 6.5% | Emotional hook, expansion, funding as a filter |
| Manufacturing / traditional | 0.9% | No signal combination worked |
EdTech is the clearest lesson. Education buyers have little budget authority, so a growth signal gives them nothing to act on. A regional offer such as "select Texas schools" plus a free 30-day pilot removed the budget question entirely. The guide's own line for it is that the offer is the signal.
B2B services responded to specific company news. A named partnership or a new market entry proves the sender did the research. A case study then proves the sender can deliver. The guide's rule is to pick the most specific news event, not the most common one.
HR tech is the one vertical where hiring is the buying trigger. A company hiring at scale needs assessment tools, so the signal and the need are the same thing. A free trial tied to their hiring volume completed the pairing.
Creative services used funding differently. Funded companies have budget for brand work, so funding decides who to email. The email itself opens with a provocative question about how they connect with their audience, written the way a creative strategist would ask it.
Recruiting dropped company signals altogether. Emails referenced how long the person had been in their role and the everyday frustrations of that role. The guide's reading is that when the buyer is the product, company news makes the email feel corporate.
The Clay table behind each playbook
For every vertical the skill lists the exact Clay columns to build. A few examples from the guide:
- EdTech: state or region, decision-maker title and district size.
- B2B services: Recent News, a custom column that classifies the news type, and a custom ICP column for the second email.
- HR tech: Open Jobs, a count of open roles for urgency, and recent awards as a secondary hook.
- Recruiting: Summarize Work History for tenure, plus role level for pain-point matching.
Each of the seven playbooks then sets the sequence length, the delays between steps, the opener formula, the tone and what to avoid. The B2B services playbook, for example, runs three steps with delays of 1, 2 and 5 days.
How to choose a signal for your own outbound
- 01Name the triggerAsk what event or condition makes this buyer more likely to need what you sell right now.
- 02Find the enrichmentPick the Clay enrichment that captures that event or condition.
- 03Build the openerWrite the first line of the email around that signal.
- 04Match offer and tonePair it with the offer type and tone that work for that vertical.
If the honest answer to the first question is "nothing specific", signal-based outreach is probably the wrong motion for that market. The guide points those teams to referrals, events and relationship building instead. For the wider picture of how signals fit a GTM system, see our guides to buying signals and signal-based selling.
Setting up the skill
Setup takes five steps. Download the skill file, open Claude and go to Projects, create a project, and upload the file to Project Knowledge. Then start a chat and ask which signals suit an EdTech campaign. You can also ask which Clay enrichments a B2B agency table needs. The skill pairs with our Cold Email Patterns skill in the same project. Claude can then pick the signal and write the email together.
Which signals show that an account really has appetite to buy?
The ones tied to the buyer's purchase trigger. In the data, hiring predicted replies in HR tech because hiring creates the need for assessment tools. The same hiring signal failed in manufacturing, where procurement has nothing to do with headcount. Ask what makes this buyer more likely to need you right now, then find the enrichment that captures it.
Do hiring signals and new-contract announcements work as intent signals?
It depends on the vertical. Hiring signals were the strongest buying trigger in HR tech and the weakest in manufacturing. Specific company news, such as a named partnership or a new market entry, worked well in B2B services. Generic growth references performed in the middle almost everywhere.
